Between the Two Ponds
One passage. One idea. A few quiet minutes. Short devotional readings for people being formed by grace, written from a small chair beside still water in Falcon, Colorado.
Pull one up. Read slowly. There is no hurry here.
Have You Reached Yet
There is a preacher who imagined the hosts of heaven leaning over the rail of glory, watching the Son of God face down in the dirt of Gethsemane, sweating like a man bleeding, and asking one another a single question.
"Father, if you are willing, remove this cup from me. Nevertheless, not my will, but yours, be done." (Luke 22:42)
One preacher imagined the hosts of heaven leaning over the rail of glory, watching the Son of God face down in the dirt of Gethsemane, sweating as though he were bleeding, and asking one another a single question. Has he reached yet, yet? Because everything hung on that one word.
Father, if you are willing, take this cup from me. That is the prayer, and it is honest, the prayer of a man who does not want to do what he is about to do. And then, nevertheless. Yet. Not my will, but yours. There is a kind of faith that only believes God exists and is good, and it is real, but it is the beginning. And there is a deeper faith, a desperate faith, that honors him, holds nothing back, and wants his glory known in the world more than it wants to be comfortable. In the moment Jesus said that one word, his heart caught fire again for his Father's glory, and the garden became the doorway to the cross.
So here is the question to leave standing in front of you. Have you reached the point of yet, yet? You may still be at the cup, and there is no shame in the cup; he was there too. But do not mistake the cup for the whole prayer. The prayer is not finished until it can say yet, and mean it, and go.
His Presence Is the Thing
That is not rhetorical, and it is not a scolding. I am genuinely asking, because I do it, and I would like to know why.
"I will never leave you nor forsake you." (Deuteronomy 31:6)
He told us he would never leave. So why do we keep behaving as though he already has? That is not a scolding. It is a real question, worth sitting with, because we all do it. If God has said it, that ought to settle it, and yet knowing a thing is true has never once been the same as being able to live inside it.
Here is what seems actually to be happening. We do not struggle to believe he is present. We struggle to believe that his presence is enough on its own, without an answer attached. We want him near, yes, but we want him near and the test to come back clean, near and the marriage restored, near and the money to arrive, and if we cannot have both, we are not entirely sure what the first one was even for.
And God will not renegotiate that. He gives you himself. He does not offer his presence as a consolation prize for the thing you actually wanted, and he does not offer it as a down payment on some future delivery. His presence is not the promise of the gift. His presence is the gift. Until that lands, every answered prayer will feel like the real point and every silence like abandonment. When it lands, you will find you were given the best thing on the first day, and have spent years treating it as the packaging around something better.
Lighter Than a Ledger
If the only time we trust God is when he gives us what we asked for, we are living in an elementary view of grace.
"For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God." (Ephesians 2:8)
If the only time we trust God is when he gives us what we asked for, we are living in an elementary view of grace. That is not a criticism of anyone who is hurting. It is a diagnosis of a whole way of relating to God that we picked up somewhere and never examined, and it runs like this: prayer is a system, input goes in, output comes out, and if the output does not come, the system has malfunctioned, and either I broke it or he did.
But grace is not a system. Grace is a person deciding to be good to you, and a person cannot be operated like a machine. You do not get leverage on love by pressing the right buttons.
And here is the thing we do not expect. The elementary view is exhausting. It is far more labor than trust. You have to monitor every outcome. You have to keep a running ledger of answered and unanswered. You have to read every ordinary event as a coded message, and when nothing happens you have to decide what the nothing says about you. Trust is lighter than that. Not easier, lighter. There is a difference, and you only discover it on the far side of laying the ledger down. So put it down. Stop auditing God for evidence of his goodness, and let grace be what it has always been, a Person, freely good, who cannot be worked but can be trusted.
No Graft Without the Knife
I want to sit with that, because we skip past it every time and it is the whole mechanism.
"But if some of the branches were broken off ... do not be arrogant toward the branches." (Romans 11:17-18)
The graft has to be cut in. Sit with that, because we skip past it every time, and it is the whole mechanism. You do not tape a branch to a tree. You do not lay it alongside and hope. The farmer takes a knife and opens the trunk, and opens the branch, and binds the two open places together, and the healing that closes over that wound is the union itself. Two woundings, held against each other until they become one thing.
Which means there is no grafting without cutting. We would all prefer a version of this faith where the sweetness comes without the knife, and people go looking for it, but the ones who claim to have found it are usually the ones whose fruit you would not want to eat. Sweetness without a wound is a flavoring, not a graft.
Christ was opened. His side was opened, his hands were opened, and it was through those openings that our life came. And you will be opened too. That is not a threat; it is how the joining is done. The place where you were cut, the loss, the humbling, the thing that broke you open, is exactly the place the good sap can finally get in, if you will let it be bound to him and not to your own bitterness. A wound bound to Christ becomes the union. A wound bound to bitterness becomes a scar that keeps everything out. Do not despise the cut. Ask whom you are being joined to through it.
Training Wheels
We love this verse and we quote it constantly and I want to say something about it that will not be popular.
"Again I say to you, if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven." (Matthew 18:19)
We love this verse, and we quote it constantly, and here is something about it that will not be popular. It was spoken to people who are not yet mature. Say that carefully. It is a promise, it is true, and God keeps it. But it is a promise handed to those who have not yet learned the intimacy of trusting God when the room goes quiet. It is training wheels, and there is no shame in training wheels. Every one of us has needed them.
Now go and read Luke 11 and Luke 18. Those chapters are written for a different reader. The friend who knocks at midnight and keeps knocking. The widow who comes back to the judge and comes back and comes back again. Those are not stories about getting an answer quickly. They are stories about people who did not leave.
That is the growth to want, for you and for me: to move from a faith that needs a visible answer to prove the line is open, into a faith that will stay in the room with God when nothing at all is coming back. Do not despise the early promise; God gave it to steady you. But do not camp there either, treating answered requests as the only proof he is near. Both are prayer. Only one of them has become friendship.
When a Savior Prays for You
I want to be very clear about that, because we tell the denial story so often that we forget how it ends.
"But I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail. And when you have turned again, strengthen your brothers." (Luke 22:32)
Peter's faith did not fail. Be clear about that, because we tell the denial story so often that we forget how it ends. He denied him three times, in a courtyard, by a fire, to a servant girl. He swore he did not know the man, and he meant it in the moment, and he wept afterward, and everything in us says that is exactly what failure looks like.
But go and find Peter at the tomb. He is running. He stoops. He looks in. And what he sees, or rather what he does not see, changes the rest of his life. His faith staggered. His faith did not fail. And it did not fail for one reason, stated out loud before it ever happened: I have prayed for you. When a Savior who is about to defeat death prays that a man's faith will not fail, it does not fail. That is not sentimentality. It is a promise with a track record.
So whatever you did last week, and whatever you are still carrying from it, hear this plainly. A denial is not the end of the story when Christ is the one praying you through it. He had a plan for Peter, and it was not a plan without bruises, and he prayed it all the way to the far side. He is doing the same for you right now, at this moment, by name. Your faith is not being held up by your grip on him. It is being held by his grip on you.
Sift and Lift
Hold those two sentences side by side, because they are the whole spiritual war in nine words, and they explain nearly everything that happens to you in a given week.
"But I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail." (Luke 22:32)
Satan's aim is to sift your faith. Jesus' aim is to lift it. Hold those two sentences side by side, because they are nearly the whole spiritual war, and between them they explain most of what happens to you in a given week.
Sifting is violent. It is a farmer throwing grain into the air and letting the wind carry off whatever is light, a thing done to wheat by someone who does not care what the wheat feels about it. Jesus says Satan demanded to have them for exactly this, to thrash them, to shake them until something came loose. And when he says Satan has asked to sift you, the word is plural. It was never only Peter. It has always been all of them, and all of us. He is not after your faith because you are special. He is after your faith because it is faith, and faith is the one thing in you he cannot devour.
Which brings us to how Jesus lifts it. Not with a lecture. Not with a strategy handed down. He says, I have prayed for you. The Son of God, on the worst night of his life, hours from a cross, spent some of his last free breath praying that a man who was about to deny him three times would not lose his grip.
And the man did not. So when you feel the wind take everything light in you, do not conclude you are being abandoned. You are being sifted, and Someone stronger than the wind has already prayed that the one thing that matters will hold. Let the chaff go, and trust the prayer that is holding the wheat.
Pride Is Dead Faith
It amazes me that Christians can know in their heads that we ought to be people of prayer and then never quite find the time for it.
"Simon, Simon, behold, Satan demanded to have you, that he might sift you like wheat." (Luke 22:31)
It is a strange thing that a Christian can know in his head that he ought to be a person of prayer and still never quite find the time for it. We know the reason, too, and we simply refuse to change it. We do not pray because our faith is not as high as we imagine, and our estimate of ourselves is higher than it should be. We are full of a quiet pride, and pride and prayer cannot hold the same heart at the same time.
Ask what keeps a person from repenting, and the answer is pride. Ask what keeps a person from seeking forgiveness, and the answer is pride. Ask what makes a person refuse to pray, and the answer has not changed. Pride is more natural to us than prayer, because pride removes the sense of need. As long as a man is self-sufficient and comfortable, he has no reason to ask God for anything, and if he is honest, no real desire for him either. It is only when a man knows he is powerless that he grows willing to listen to Christ and go and do what he says.
That is why prayerlessness is not mainly a problem of the calendar. It is a problem of pride. Prayer interrupts a man in the middle of his own ambition and requires him to confess he cannot manage his life alone, and pride will do almost anything to avoid that confession.
And here is the sharp end of it. A faith that will not bend to the grace and power of the cross is not faith at all, but a forgery, and it was minted by pride. Pride is dead faith. So do not first go hunting for more time to pray. Go hunting for the pride that has been quietly telling you that you do not need to.
The Intimacy of Silence
Here is a sentence that took something out of me when I first wrote it, and I have not been able to soften it since.
"Trust in the Lord with all your heart, and do not lean on your own understanding." (Proverbs 3:5)
Here is a hard sentence. If Jesus must give you an exact answer to every prayer, then he cannot yet trust you with the intimacy of his silence. Read it again, slowly.
We think of the silence as a withholding, a punishment, an absence, or at best a delay. And so we grade our prayer lives by what we can point at. This is the answer. This is what he did. Look what came through. But if the only time we will trust God is when he hands us what we asked for, and the only answers we will accept are the ones our senses can verify, then we are living in a very elementary view of grace. That is a child's faith, and there is no shame in beginning there, for every one of us does, and God is patient with beginners.
But he has more for you than the beginning. There is a kind of nearness that exists only in the quiet, a knowing between two people who no longer need to fill the room with words. A husband and wife find it after twenty years. Old friends have it on a porch, saying nothing, and closer for it. That intimacy cannot be given to a person who demands proof every time, because the demand keeps the whole relationship at the level of a transaction.
So turn the question around from the one you have been asking. You have been asking whether you can trust God in the silence. Ask instead whether he can trust you with it, whether he can be quiet with you and know you will not go looking for a god who talks more.
Because He Loved Them, He Waited
We waited for the internet to dial up, back when a connection was a thing that had to be built each time, with sound. We waited by the phone for a call, and mostly we did not know who was calling until we picked it up.
"So when he heard that Lazarus was sick, he stayed where he was two more days." (John 11:6)
There was a time when waiting was simply the shape of a life. A connection to the wider world had to be built each time, with sound and delay. A call came, and you did not know who it was until you picked it up. A dial turned all the way around, one number at a time, and a single mistake meant starting over. Waiting was not a failure of the system. It was the system. We have nearly lost the skill, and losing it has made us worse at prayer, because prayer still runs on the old system.
Watch what John does in this passage, because it is almost cruel in its plainness. The sisters send word: Lord, the one you love is sick. It is a good message, honest and urgent and full of faith. Then verse five says that Jesus loved Martha and her sister and Lazarus. And then verse six says, so, when he heard that Lazarus was sick, he stayed where he was two more days.
Read those verses against each other and do not rush past the hinge. So. Because he loved them, he waited. That is not the sentence any of us would have written. We would have written, because he loved them, he came at once. But it is the sentence that is there, and it means the delay was not the failure of his love. It was an expression of it. So when he waits with you, do not conclude that he does not care. The waiting itself may be the love, doing something for you that you cannot yet see.
On His Terms
I ask because I think we have quietly built a version of Christianity that lets people come to him on theirs, and I do not think we did it on purpose. I think we did it out of urgency. We wanted him to be accessible. We wanted the door to be wide.
"When Simon Peter saw it, he fell down at Jesus' knees, saying, Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, O Lord." (Luke 5:8)
Are you willing to come to Jesus on his terms? The question matters, because we have quietly built a version of the faith that lets people come to him on theirs, and I do not think it was done on purpose. It was done out of urgency. We wanted him accessible. We wanted the door wide. And somewhere in the widening, we made him optional. Pray this prayer. Sign this card. Raise your hand while every head is bowed.
There is a familiar scene at the county fair. A tent, big letters, free gifts, and the stated goal of winning souls, which is a thing any Christian should want. But the method is often this: stop the people walking past, share a few lines, and if they say yes, write the name on a list, hand them a small gift, and move to the next one. Names collected. Heads bowed. A prayer said. And then they are sent back out into a world that will eat them alive, and no one follows up, no one disciples them, no one walks with them.
It is not that God cannot save a person in a field in an afternoon. He can, and he does. The ache is over what usually happens next, which is nothing. A decision was gathered, but no one was made a disciple.
So ask it honestly, of your own faith first. Is that what following Jesus has been reduced to, a prayer, a pamphlet, and a free gift? Or have you come to him on his terms, which is not to add him to your life but to fall at his knees and hand it over?
The Bill With No Invoice
We are used to thinking of wealth as a blessing, especially here, especially as American Christians, and I do not think we notice how much of that we absorbed from the country rather than from the book.
"Life does not consist in an abundance of possessions." (Luke 12:15)
We are used to thinking of wealth as a blessing, and here especially, and we rarely notice how much of that we absorbed from our country rather than from our Bible. God is not saying wealth is evil. Abraham had great wealth and is our father in faith. David was a king and a man after God's own heart. Money is not the enemy. What God says is, beware. Beware, because it is a dangerous thing to want more.
And the danger does not arrive looking like a warning. It arrives looking like a promotion. More from the work also means more responsibility. More responsibility means more hours. More hours means more time away from the very people you were working for in the first place. The raise comes with a bill attached, and no one itemizes it, and you pay it in a currency you do not think of as money, which is the only reason you are willing to spend so much of it.
That is exactly how the carrot works. You get it. You actually get it. And getting it quietly costs you the thing you wanted it for, and you do not notice for years, because no one ever sends the invoice. The loss is real, but it is never billed.
So this is not a sermon against money, which is not evil, and which you would not believe anyway. It is one question, and it is worth sitting still with. What did your last raise cost you? Not what did it pay. What did it cost, and did anyone ever send you the bill, or are you only now beginning to add it up?
What It Is Built On
And there are people on the outside preaching Christ specifically to make his imprisonment hurt more. Rivals. Men using the gospel as a weapon against a man in chains, out of envy, out of ambition, hoping to afflict him while he cannot answer back.
"What then? Only that in every way, whether in pretense or in truth, Christ is proclaimed, and in that I rejoice." (Philippians 1:18)
Paul writes this from prison, and it is worse than prison, because there are men on the outside preaching Christ precisely to make his chains hurt more. Rivals. Men using the gospel as a weapon against a man who cannot answer back, out of envy and ambition, hoping to afflict him while he sits helpless. And what does he say about them? He says Christ is being preached, and I rejoice.
It should stop us, because most of us cannot do it. Someone takes a shot at us and we carry it for a week. Someone builds himself up by pulling us down and we rehearse the conversation in the shower for days. But Paul looks straight through their motives and finds Christ standing behind them, and that is enough for him. Actually enough.
Comfort has become so treasured a thing in our faith that we can scarcely grasp that faith might be uncomfortable, that it might cost, that the way forward might require us to see past a whole cloud of unfairness and misrepresentation, find Christ above it, and keep walking. Paul could do that because his life was not built on being treated fairly. It was built on Christ, and Christ was not going anywhere, and so neither was he.
The question is not whether you will be treated unfairly. You will. The question is what your life is built on underneath the unfairness, because a life built on fair treatment collapses the first time the treatment is unfair. What is yours built on? You will find out the day it is taken.
When the Comfort Goes
We live in a culture that is deeply and unashamedly committed to comfort.
"Only let your manner of life be worthy of the gospel of Christ." (Philippians 1:27)
We live in a culture unashamedly committed to comfort. Get better things. Build a bigger house. Book the next vacation before this one has ended. Maximize the safety and minimize the friction. From every direction the same dream is pressed on us, a life without friction, and it seeps so quietly into faith that we seldom say it out loud. So say it out loud and test it. Does following Christ lead to your ultimate comfort in this life? Is being a Christian a promise of an easier road?
If we are honest, that is close to what many of us signed up for, whether we would admit it or not, and it is the unnamed assumption beneath a hundred small disappointments with God. Here is the part that should sober every one of us. A person can have a good family and good standing, a nice house and a healthy retirement, real knowledge of the Bible and genuine belief in Jesus. A person can come on Sunday when it is convenient, feel the hair rise on the back of the neck during a song, take the sacrament, serve on a team, do every good thing the faith offers, and still not have a life centered on Christ. The mind knows. The heart has never recognized.
And the only way any of us ever finds out which one we are is when the comfort goes. Comfort insulates the question. Loss exposes it. When the house, the health, the standing, the ease are stripped back, what remains standing is what was actually at the center all along. So do not wait for the stripping to find out. Ask now, while it is easy, whether you are following Christ or following comfort, and move him to the center on purpose, before loss does it for you.
Two Sides of the Same Gift
Read that verse again slowly, because there is a word in it that most of us skip.
"For it has been granted to you that for the sake of Christ you should not only believe in him but also suffer for his sake." (Philippians 1:29)
Read the verse slowly, because there is a word in it most of us skip. Granted. It has been granted to you, given to you as a gift. And what has been given? Two things, joined in the same sentence and handed over in the same act: not only to believe in him, but also to suffer for him.
We have no trouble with the first half. Faith is a gift, we can preach that in our sleep. By grace you have been saved through faith, and this is not your own doing, it is the gift of God. But watch what Paul has done. He has taken faith and taken suffering, laid them side by side, and called them both a gift. They are two sides of one coin.
Consider what that means. A coin has a head and a tail. It can land either way up and it is still the same coin, still worth the same, and no one holds one up and says, this one landed tails, so it is worth less. Whether you are believing or whether you are suffering, you are holding the same coin. It is all one life of faith, all the same gift, given by the same hand.
This is not said lightly or from a comfortable chair. But it changes the question we bring to God in the dark. We are forever asking why the coin landed the way it did, as though suffering were proof the gift had been taken back. It was not. It is still the coin he gave you, still faith, still grace, still his. Stop demanding to know why it fell as it did, turn it over in your hand, and see that it is the same gift on both sides.
Believing and Surrendering
There is a flaw that can hide inside the way we share the gospel, and I have fallen into it myself.
"For to me, to live is Christ, and to die is gain." (Philippians 1:21)
There is a flaw that can hide inside the way we speak about faith. You ask someone about theirs, and they tell you they believe in a higher power, and you say what you have said a hundred times, you have to believe in Jesus, and they answer, I do believe in him. And there we stop, satisfied, certain something has happened. But there is a difference between believing and surrendering, and the whole of the Christian life is lived in the gap between them.
Believing is the first step. It acknowledges that Jesus is real, that he existed, that he is who he said he was. That is something. It is not nothing. But it is not yet enough, because belief has a second step to take, and the second step is surrender. To place your faith in Christ is not merely to be persuaded of him. It is to hand yourself over.
For most of us it begins in the mind. Who is the way, the truth, the life. Jesus. And then, slowly, what the mind holds about Christ works its way down out of the head and into the depths of the heart, where affection actually lives, and faith moves from believing in Christ to living for him. That is Paul's whole sentence. For me to live is Christ. Not, for me to be convinced of Christ. To live is Christ.
Even the demons believe, and tremble. Belief that costs nothing and changes nothing is not yet the thing that saves. So ask yourself the question plainly, the one that goes underneath mere agreement. Do you believe in Jesus, or have you given him your life? A great many people can answer the first. He is asking the second.
The Second Oxygen
Two parts hydrogen and one oxygen gives you water. Add a second oxygen and the same elements will kill you. We are rarely wrong about the ingredients of our faith. We go wrong in how we combine them.
"Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is one." (Deuteronomy 6:4)
Two parts hydrogen and one part oxygen, and you have water. You can drink it and live. Add one more oxygen and you have hydrogen peroxide, and it will take you apart from the inside. The elements did not change. The arrangement did.
That is what should unsettle us about our faith, because we are rarely wrong about the ingredients. We say Father, Son, Spirit. We say sin, we say grace. Ask almost anyone and they will hand the words back correctly. But the words are not the thing. What matters is how they are combined, and whether you have quietly added a second oxygen. Grace, held together with the Father who loves you, makes a life. Grace held next to a small view of sin makes permission. The same word, a different arrangement. Holiness, held together with grace, makes a saint. Holiness held next to fear makes a Pharisee, and Pharisees are built entirely out of true things.
You do not usually go wrong by believing something false. You go wrong by holding true things in a combination that will not carry life. Which is why Moses does not begin with a list. He begins with an arrangement. The Lord our God, the Lord is one. Not a Father you go to for comfort, and a Judge you avoid, and a Spirit you call on when desperate. One. And the love he asks for is not divided either: all your heart, all your soul, all your strength. So look at what you actually believe today. Not the words, you have those. The arrangement. What have you set beside grace, so that it cannot be all his? You may not be far off at all. You may only be one oxygen away.
